Fe107 replaces wrc 107 as a calculation tool that can be applied when wrc 107 correlational methods are limited. In this article the shrink ring method is compared with calculation methods from wrc bulletin 107 and bs 5500, appendix g. Customers are mainly demanding calculation of the bearings basic rating life according to iso 281. You can also click view report using microsoft word on the wrc 107297 toolbar to perform the initial wrc 107 calculation and summation and send the results directly to microsoft word. When the tt ratio for a loaded nozzle is less than 1. If you are an existing prg customer, we highly recommend that you keep your existing licenses on support, or reinstate support before march 31, 2020 extended to april 30, 2020. In some cases, it is not possible to build such directly welded parts in pv elite due to software continue reading lifting lug wrc calculation. I have four different vessels, so i wont mention specific thicknesses here. Jan 30, 2014 find the maximum loads that can be placed on nozzles using compress. Overview of api 5791asme ffs1 with an emphasis on data and inspection requirements. Bildy, is the principal author of part 4, paragraph 4. Asme section viii pressure vessel nozzle load application.
Hanger spans support locations are dependent on pipe size, piping. The contents of both wrc 107 and wrc 537 are same but the later one is in more useful and clear format. Fea so that users can know when 107 or 297 calculations are accurate enough. Welding research council wrc bulletin 297 and 107 elite. It is observed from the analysis that with the case of stress indices stress are very high in nature. What code should i select wrc 107, wrc297, wrc 537. The analysis results indicated that fea offered more. The most stringent case caused by axial load f a acting inward or outward shall be considered. All directly welded parts to the pressure vessel like lifting lugs, support lug, trunnion etc. For longitudinal moment loading on a nozzle, the above formula is. I am trying to create an excel sheet to calculate nozzles according to wrc 107 wrc 537. This is why in the caesar ii documentation wrc297 is used at the input stage, and wrc107 was used in this specific example for the subsequent local evaluation.
The pressure stress equations used in the designcalcs implementation of the wrc 107method are for primary membrane stress caused from internal pressure. In fact, due to the nature of the engineering problem the existence of combination of 3 forces and 3 moments to derive a single stress intensity there is an infinite set of loads that will all produce the maximum stress in the shell as per the wrc 107 analysis. The table below shows an example of the output from fe107 source axial inplane outofplane torsion fea 9. Wrc 107 presents stresses at points picked for ease of calculation and does not present the stress patterns available from fe analysis.
How does pv elite calculate nozzles that falls out of wrc107. Basically, the wrc 107 297 ignores the stresses due to the internal or external pressure. External loads on solid round attachments on cylindrical shells. Influence of nozzle stiffness on equipment nozzle loads. Some methods evaluate stress in the cylindrical or spherical shell e.
Compute loads on nozzle by performing piping flexibility analysis. Supplementary bulletin wrc 297 contains directions to calculate local stresses in nozzle too, other than those in shell. Wrc 107 analysis for attachments to vessels using codecalc. Tutorial on evaluation of nozzles by computing local shell stresses. Findings from this study is then applied to wrc bulletin 107 to estimate the stresses in the nozzle region. Nozzle loads part 1 piping engineering knowledge base. Keywords stress analysis, wrc 107, wrc 297, finite elements, pressure vessel, nozzle and shell. For more complex shapes, numerical analyis allows optimization and cost reduction. External nozzle loads design using wrc107537 youtube. Axial bearing load the mean axial load is calculated by considering the dynamic axial forces on the axlebox.
I have applied also the nozzle loads on it and performed the wrc 107 calculation. Both these programs are able to calculate the local stresses with higher accuracy. Wrc 107 calculations solid mechanics chemical product. The calculation sheet has a lin bac to the web page for this product. Note that because of the reversal of the load direction the radial load p may have different maximum values depending upon its direction. Hanger spans support locations are dependent on pipe size, piping configuration, the location of heavy valves and fittings, and the. The stresses caused by the external loads are typically classified as primary local stressand.
From the comparison of fea with wrc 107 and wrc 297 results its easy to know if you should feel comfortable with a design. Load definition is one of the biggest mistakes in nozzle analysis. For this, you can use depending on the nozzle type. Axial force, two lateral force, torsional moment and two bending moments as shown in figure 1. When the dd ratio for a loaded nozzle is greater than 0. This is why in the caesar ii documentation wrc 297 is used at the input stage, and wrc 107 was used in this specific example. Convert forcesmoments from caesar ii global coordinates. A study of wrc bulletin 297 is performed to better understand the variables used in the bulletin to determine stresses in the vesselnozzle intersection. Wrc 107 now wrc 537 while others evaluate stresses in cylindrical shells and nozzles e. Stresses in nozzle shell junctions due to external loads. Stress intensities on the shellside of the juncture are provided as in wrc bulletin 537 107.
The local stresses in the wrc 107 calculation are excessive. Background wrc 297 is a very important bulletin for piping design engineers. Fe107 uses finite element technology to provide stress analysis of nozzle connections on piping and pressure vessel. Sample flange app 2 fig 245 sample flange dimensions inside diameter b 16. Pv elite does not have fea built in, but will give warning when the dd ratios etc are exceeded. A sample flange shown below will be calculated using asme appendix 2 methods and by finite element analysis fea to illustrate the application of the loads and show the resulting stresses. The wrc 107 dialog contains several options to solve for the maximum value of one of the following. This step is similar to collecting the data by hand. The extreme fiber elongation exceeds 5 percent and the thickness exceeds 58 inch heat treatment per ucs56 is required if fabricated by cold forming. Pressure vessel calculations, codes and ug22 codeware.
The more recent wrc bulletin 537 facilitates more efficient and accurate implementation of wrc bulletin 107 through precise equations and data fitting techniques. Secondary stress indices for integral structural attachments to. Allowable stresses and safety factors asme ii part d s allowable tensile stress. All forces and moments in the above tables are positive and sign rotation is as per wrc bulletin 107. In the case of nozzles subject to external loads, the stresses can be here. Wrc bulletin 107 297 368 wrc limitation and usage quiz. S a allowable tensile stress under normal conditions. Local stresses are also calculated with wrc 297 module and these are tabulated compared with allowable stresses in next section. Example of membrane stress in a cylinder subject to internal pressure. Sample vessel 8 pvesample 8 pressure vessel calculations april 27, 2007 xyz vessel inc. If the stresses are found to be within those allowable values, then the nozzle loads computed by pipe stress analysis are considered as acceptable. What code should i select wrc107, wrc297, wrc537 in. Wrc bulletins 107, 198, and 297, asme code cases n318 and n392, or through a detailed finite element analysis.
Wrc bulletin 297 applies only to nozzles on cylindrical shells loaded by p, v, m and t loads and where the nozzle is circular and hollow. Prg is moving to subscription only licensing model starting in 2020. Generally, the nozzles of an asme section viii pressure vessel can be checked with hand calculations. Software shall use appropriate code year for analysis.
Analysis of stress in nozzleshell of cylindrical pressure. Local stresses in cylindrical shells due to external loadings on a radial flush nozzle. However, unlike wrc bulletin 537 107, stress intensities are also provided on the nozzle side of the juncture. One of the most important steps in the wrc 107 procedure is to identify the correlation between the caesar ii global coordinates and the wrc 107 local axes. The actual preparation of the wrc 107 calculation input can now begin. Each load creates some types of local stresses such as membrane or bending stresses in two directions. We would like to show you a description here but the site wont allow us. So, an attempt is made to do the stress analysis of reactor nozzle to head. Stresses at reactor nozzle to head junction are obtained using welding research council wrc 107 and pvcodecalc software 2008 with and without stress indices. Now i need to take a look at how the lifting lugs will act on the vessel wall. How to validate an attachment nozzle or support according. Based on the basic equation of theory of thin shells, analysed every. Compress and pv elite, both use the newer version of the bulletin, wrc 537.
After the input echo, the parameters extracted from the wrc 107 figures are printed to this report. All related calculations are carried out in pv elite once given proper inputs. I guess what it boils down to is that im looking for is a clarification of the wrc 107 sign convention. Paulin research group moving to subscription only license model in 2020. Codeware personnel are actively involved with the american society of mechanical engineers asme. Convert forcesmoments from caesar ii global coordinates to. Wrc 537 vs fea boiler and pressure vessel engineering. Stiffness values from wrc 297 analysis above stiffness values are used in piping stress analysis to evaluate nozzle loads and these are compared with equipment vendor allowable loads in results section. A simple nozzle on a flat head is a perfect example of a structure that can be idealized as a cantilever beam. When the nozzle is pad reinforced and wrc 107 or 297 is considered for use. Wrc bulletin 297 broadens and expands upon the methodologies of wrc bulletin 107.
Compress and inspect pressure vessel calculations provide ug22 compliance and include asme viii, api 579, wrc 107, wrc 297, wrc 537, zick, asce, nbc, asme 16. For dished ends, the resultant shear force and bending moment are calculated as. In the first step, you have to choose which curve you want to use, on the basis of beta en tau. Wrc 107 presents results for inside and outside of the shell at quarter points. You can also click view report using microsoft word on the wrc 107 297 toolbar to perform the initial wrc 107 calculation and summation and send the results directly to microsoft word. When i run calculations, i get deficiencies on 3 nozzles. Find the maximum loads that can be placed on nozzles using compress.
Request pdf stresses in nozzle shell junctions due to external loads. Upon reading wrc 537, i believe that it is due to the gamma ratio being less than 5 which falls outside of the data range. Wrc 107297 calculation from analysis menu intergraph. Tutorial on evaluation of nozzles by computing local shell. The code allowable stress is about here, below yield. Users not familiar with finite element method prefer to use calculations based on wrc 107 297.
Due to liability lawsuits bentley can not provide design details such as this. Wrc 107 supports 6 external loads in local stress calculation. Sample vessel 8 pve sample 8 pressure vessel calculations april 27, 2007 xyz vessel inc. General the wrc 107 method only considers external loads and does not consider pressure. Various methods have been in use for the determination of stresses at the nozzleshell junction due to external loads and moments. Calculation modules for rtod, asme, tema, ejma, ad2000 and en445. The mpc lotcentered analysis method for determining high temperature strength parameters. Autopipe vessel considers the stresses due to the pressure and uses a weld joint efficiency equal to 1 in reference of the ug37 where the thicknesses due to the pressure are calculated for the opening reinforcement equal to 1. The following wrc 107 graphs were used in the calculations pertaining to the scf.
247 1612 909 62 286 1379 490 319 1385 1480 1220 292 1173 985 899 1370 950 1087 1115 196 1581 1487 215 1112 782 630 1327 785 1343 420 650 1201 643